Results for oxford_elastic

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used (article_oxford_elastic.pdf)

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.0000701.3323100.22545523.00000042.00000036.950000
Fissures 0.05733524.8574008.30217425.00000044.00000041.716667
Landmarks 1.72311042.06680014.50893540.00000044.00000042.250000
Singularities 0.0000001.2746600.13095915.50000040.00000033.466667
Average 38.595833

Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.8341730.4741140.9063720.4913250.65541737.5
02 0.1806000.0000510.0000000.1715090.09324741
03 0.0416720.0012590.0000390.0418670.02210439
04 0.0298210.0072930.0330110.0000000.01662641
05 0.0090550.0248190.0000000.0319080.01679340
06 0.0001380.0000000.0000000.0001280.00007040
07 0.4494240.5346260.9500590.1533290.49056234
08 0.0620520.0239150.0321320.0524660.04349336
09 0.0002780.0330160.0019840.0285990.01639139
10 0.2069990.1049250.2918940.0006040.14727141
11 0.0651530.0465210.0633340.0501080.05578726
12 0.1054940.0130870.0089670.1049390.06081938
13 0.0007500.0074550.0000870.0074690.00405034
14 0.4388230.5351260.7278320.2864440.48780035
15 1.0331301.1274401.4770600.7686671.07903042
16 0.2109610.0899350.0000000.2666690.15198040
17 0.0000000.0002170.0000000.0002170.00011423
18 0.5225690.6886131.0726300.2366960.60529937
19 0.1522100.0189560.0559770.1145290.08971640
20 0.3161260.3918180.6830650.0869730.35379438
21 1.8819800.7651632.3066800.6509721.33231035
22 0.0136820.0324310.0003350.0424960.02281931
23 0.0216280.0006780.0004480.0193280.01119336
24 0.0113540.0031710.0115270.0022380.00671836
25 0.0634550.0020160.0001540.0616700.03338138
26 0.0596730.0000000.0000000.0502150.02896140
27 0.4844860.0579030.0833640.4275300.27271941
28 0.9424260.2455940.5172690.6552030.59504836
29 0.0115380.0075270.0192790.0000240.00930237
30 0.0331960.0897460.0915230.0359860.06084937
Avg 0.272762 0.177580 0.311167 0.161337 0.225455 36.950000

Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 8.85467027.24190023.64250042.5
02 0.3289871.1278700.83026941
03 9.7421200.5215552.92893044
04 0.0000000.1782120.09567543
05 23.59340014.77780020.44810044
06 0.0125810.2955500.18474442
07 5.67320014.8455009.93777041
08 21.1252006.73970012.61490043
09 8.3312700.3846973.19495043
10 0.0000001.8183000.67153943
11 8.29330023.58000018.52520043
12 9.4172403.9557805.81505043
13 3.7592100.1948632.50868043
14 7.44006014.48220011.20650037
15 0.52997013.2590007.49431042
16 5.09846019.78520016.25860043
17 0.5041180.4233090.45467142
18 13.44950032.29420024.85740043
19 1.0210000.8083770.90266243
20 1.7741602.8894802.46379025
21 4.99598011.7066009.56277040
22 0.3460941.9001101.10445043
23 15.3226008.99887011.51890041
24 0.4029410.0000000.07378042
25 0.0499780.9789930.63449041
26 0.1366040.0444980.07145541
27 12.26780012.82460012.60250043
28 26.68290022.07290023.72120044
29 0.2677810.0000000.05733542
30 6.56490035.96970024.68210044
Avg 6.532867 9.136659 8.302174 41.716667

Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 8.92430026.78900012.31590042.00120025.4802004.71802066.34520033.57550042.5
02 1.4625004.3890001.6031205.6908204.6572600.70000012.4084005.19471041
03 5.0695302.7020002.7703105.7731808.7664700.70312517.3354007.23989041
04 3.2182806.0356201.6721109.1778105.8931401.20773016.5307007.51096042
05 4.4887508.7640004.18687011.74010011.5405000.65625020.27740011.64230044
06 0.9201560.7950000.6581251.8995601.6238600.0000003.9519801.72311041
07 6.25711021.8680007.89680035.92630016.9515000.00000055.06750026.07960043
08 3.8100009.7510006.04500016.36220010.9703000.75000023.64430013.45050043
09 4.1835905.4390006.98633011.4946009.6671201.68122019.99460010.59910042
10 4.2887109.1071603.03638013.5767008.8120601.20773020.01080011.15880043
11 3.54098015.9250004.25061023.08540012.0821002.86719036.97370017.79300044
12 4.9082202.9540003.1248208.4112506.4616900.00000018.9814007.33899043
13 1.6894503.0375001.1035204.6929603.5314800.00000012.6517004.06576042
14 9.89262026.3760007.42113041.31060019.7333001.50822056.85970030.73770043
15 9.04922021.7280004.43672032.35770018.6514000.70000042.91470024.68220043
16 1.6601605.6250002.7929707.6630606.9336800.97656217.6357007.28378043
17 1.4550701.6400001.4746103.1019903.4642600.00000010.3400003.20660042
18 5.92676025.8860007.08887036.13190021.7347006.40352054.48450028.93330043
19 6.8517205.5510006.03656013.6579009.7595600.70000034.51900011.86470043
20 8.03539018.8650005.25293030.67910011.8797001.45315052.94930022.78330043
21 10.79580033.77140016.06210059.29430028.5585003.226300105.08500042.06680040
22 3.7500004.0320002.6250006.5006407.1811600.70000019.1687006.88173041
23 1.4746104.7500002.1484407.2921404.8312900.00000015.1266005.98789040
24 4.3002004.6975703.54004010.4746003.8199300.91477514.8021007.67659041
25 4.4007007.0280003.68266011.1579008.7867900.99771423.13950010.09090042
26 1.1753901.0050000.8227732.5651001.7401600.0000005.2655902.11963041
27 5.85035013.0690005.65383019.87030013.4785004.23831034.68310016.54660043
28 7.73906025.62700010.06080039.90490023.1471005.16211054.73170030.79180043
29 3.1113704.3533403.2589909.0508903.5834500.91477516.7444006.69862042
30 6.23809012.78200010.74650024.59580014.6896001.06360045.38700019.54370043
Avg 4.815603 11.144753 4.958494 18.181363 10.947025 1.448343 30.933656 14.508935 42.250000

Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.8981530.8645231.3450900.4124000.87874738.5
02 0.0055800.0025930.0033100.0047830.00404636
03 0.0194400.0000300.0000000.0187180.00935937
04 0.0642880.0179990.0687990.0024870.03564337
05 0.0036940.0213940.0082880.0172130.01275040
06 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000018.5
07 0.3021760.6893420.9178060.0567950.48730138
08 0.0187230.0145140.0076310.0254010.01651634
09 0.0033920.0152650.0037930.0152730.00953339
10 0.0648460.0292120.0826810.0029720.04282636
11 0.0912140.0389800.0648310.0584880.06165934
12 0.0052490.0029130.0045960.0033240.00396038
13 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000015.5
14 0.2638020.1244090.2635180.1240680.19379336
15 0.0122040.0194640.0082680.0237860.01602734
16 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000017.5
17 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000016.5
18 0.3224860.1889930.4408110.0686590.25473535
19 0.0222220.0020480.0058420.0153320.01058740
20 0.2239260.1579570.1988110.1765150.18766337
21 1.6773500.9176891.6150700.9342441.27466035
22 0.0093630.0170350.0124180.0144210.01341935
23 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000016.5
24 0.0389120.0018290.0341520.0000420.01709738
25 0.0050820.0088220.0085730.0055130.00704338
26 0.0004510.0000000.0000000.0004100.00020537
27 0.0234420.0058480.0148960.0137840.01434037
28 0.5755240.1367410.2186450.4583050.33847537
29 0.0280800.0041260.0285190.0000000.01425936
30 0.0203010.0274410.0179150.0303180.02411737
Avg 0.156663 0.110305 0.179142 0.082775 0.130959 33.466667