Results for nparbr

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used (article_nparbr.pdf)

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.0000006.8487501.97772614.50000042.00000035.400000
Fissures 0.00000013.5872002.55263113.00000043.00000032.183333
Landmarks 0.17643113.5489005.03523325.00000039.00000035.533333
Singularities 6.0718e-061.0982500.12565829.00000040.00000035.633333
Average 34.687500

Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 7.2165606.4535605.8729207.4949506.84875042
02 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000014.5
03 0.0046640.3226990.0009650.3020940.15759741
04 0.0117000.0010150.0108190.0000000.00545033
05 0.0000000.0000590.0000000.0000560.00002934
06 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000018.5
07 3.3723507.3180302.1643907.5519705.26840042
08 1.7621603.7298100.4363824.5256302.71612041
09 0.2159210.5183350.1175840.5746100.36469640
10 4.4585304.2492207.3565701.2725604.33626042
11 4.1378902.5982801.7705204.5747403.36561042
12 1.0352700.3927980.1041331.2469900.72489041
13 0.0148080.0069980.0046390.0164590.01095735
14 5.2732905.1470801.7166608.1724505.20909041
15 0.0000000.0003440.0000000.0003050.00016727
16 0.0132160.0000000.0000000.0119600.00678630
17 0.0042570.0014670.0000000.0053170.00279334
18 6.4131606.7881704.0669808.5925106.59939041
19 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000018.0
20 4.5400904.9329403.7896805.4899704.73492042
21 5.4085305.9537404.7838606.3171105.67664040
22 2.3396402.1438400.8469943.4997502.24422040
23 0.0090100.0090440.0000000.0160070.00902734
24 1.4906801.2480102.7269800.0724791.35395040
25 0.0000000.0000000.0000000.0000000.00000016.0
26 0.0016820.0000580.0000000.0014650.00084533
27 0.0426100.0591400.0536930.0484020.05080537
28 5.0094206.0157302.7429707.7003405.51078042
29 3.7774103.1351906.9512700.1312193.42049042
30 0.9706170.4363090.2344701.1087900.71313339
Avg 1.917449 2.048729 1.525083 2.290938 1.977726 35.400000

Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 1.0531502.4755502.19711030
02 0.0000000.0000000.00000017.0
03 0.0377250.0038800.01271637
04 0.0032110.0000000.00148739
05 0.0000000.0000000.00000017.5
06 0.0235890.0000000.00923735
07 6.7305702.2379904.64180034
08 1.7188503.2527602.62629034
09 0.0002060.1875500.12129736
10 0.7066290.0000000.44565541
11 6.6253501.0590702.89967035
12 3.4731204.2461103.98296039
13 2.2664900.1069041.50881039
14 9.81444016.86830013.58720040
15 0.0000000.0238300.01303832
16 0.0000000.0681950.05182020
17 0.5893217.3268504.71204043
18 14.2125005.0951208.69317037
19 0.0000000.0000000.00000013.0
20 15.1123006.5237109.80174038
21 3.1237202.0891102.41964027
22 0.0262191.4959800.74346137
23 7.5976203.0652404.87145036
24 0.0000000.0000000.00000016.0
25 0.0000000.0003300.00020733
26 0.0101730.0000000.00297730.0
27 0.0123002.6167901.57825039
28 2.57662015.17090010.66790035
29 0.0000000.0000000.00000017.0
30 2.5409900.0220570.98899539
Avg 2.608503 2.464541 2.552631 32.183333

Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 4.6694504.7530003.5207807.0132209.9547901.52902020.9705008.51342034
02 0.2812500.3360000.3164060.6333920.8145870.0000001.7210200.72036630
03 1.7929701.5820001.6242203.0426103.6883700.0000007.4930003.35903038
04 1.9239703.0894501.0774306.3653201.9737400.4687508.7849504.13676037
05 0.0918750.0560000.0656250.1029410.2529200.0000001.6796800.17643125
06 0.4265620.9000000.3900001.2116001.3845000.0000004.7017801.32225038
07 6.5896905.4110003.8594508.87279012.0644000.70000026.10410010.37990037
08 2.8950004.1440001.7025003.9134707.5180300.70000019.0597005.85993038
09 1.5244102.2680001.6201203.1178904.3924000.6835949.9184903.74240038
10 3.2602605.9102501.78405011.7693003.2818900.89410816.1950007.46224038
11 2.8241803.3390001.9568603.9623707.4821300.70000017.6685005.54184039
12 3.5823102.2400002.9775004.9884506.7902901.04462013.5819005.97947039
13 1.2109401.2000000.9082032.1012702.5452400.0000007.1735802.34101037
14 9.7924204.9630004.62234012.92990014.1933001.68889029.86360013.54890038
15 0.5062500.7140000.5554690.9065821.6023000.0000006.3779901.29619035
16 0.5371090.9500000.4785161.1020701.8890300.00000010.0476001.51129026
17 1.0156201.6400000.7324202.3592302.7026100.00000010.4660002.47000038
18 7.9228504.0670002.8095707.87425012.8518001.36719023.99290010.36300037
19 0.3451560.3290000.3157810.7150660.8222680.0000002.5048900.76437931
20 6.9593408.5260002.80156012.07910012.5916003.07598023.86820012.29430037
21 7.8116204.3642904.1179308.37210013.2672002.37234024.45920010.93400034
22 4.1093802.5900002.0000004.6200506.9153300.78125010.9904005.90540038
23 0.4296870.7250000.3222660.9652381.5009200.0000005.0944701.24915030
24 3.3014503.9612301.1707708.1451102.0739400.48828111.3903005.59246038
25 0.3910160.2450000.4123440.7026280.8951400.0000005.9156100.78925834
26 0.4494140.7650000.3941021.0380601.4388600.0000003.4366901.25449035
27 1.7309203.7100001.6024203.7216805.8421000.00000011.6990004.82430037
28 4.8964505.7330003.4900207.57836011.0523001.58548025.9483009.30904035
29 2.9524003.6975501.1014707.7626701.7392700.48828113.9315005.17120039
30 1.9138701.6730002.6025404.3160704.1758800.00000011.6624004.24458036
Avg 2.871261 2.796059 1.711089 4.742760 5.256571 0.618926 12.890042 5.035233 35.533333

Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.1107220.1855680.0003460.3074770.15391231
02 0.0000000.0010190.0000000.0010460.00052334
03 0.0631730.0193270.0092350.0715670.04040139
04 0.1893820.2040360.2955900.1013100.19845038
05 0.0000000.0224420.0000000.0229650.01148238
06 0.0433280.1518740.0364170.1578690.09714340
07 0.1092210.0770900.0027340.1849810.09385732
08 0.0712610.0602220.0003100.1306380.06547438
09 0.0171200.0021210.0016650.0170590.00936237
10 1.4515100.8798301.5480300.6484661.09825039
11 0.0825860.1154320.0016780.2006630.10117137
12 0.0088930.0009410.0004020.0086120.00450738
13 0.0057210.0015030.0000000.0075220.00376134
14 0.1018260.1307760.0829530.1497780.11636633
15 0.0187340.0241690.0000000.0431920.02159635
16 0.0356870.0816390.0121350.1126600.06239737
17 0.0273150.0081910.0000000.0335160.01675836
18 0.0828320.0886590.0012930.1702860.08578930
19 0.0005120.0000000.0000000.0004330.00021733
20 0.1556520.2038760.0346620.3296600.18216135
21 0.1833380.1467960.0000500.3278840.16396729
22 0.0774270.0732760.0252500.1252140.07523237
23 0.0838700.0193910.0396140.0601860.04990038
24 0.3535570.7599300.3871390.7980920.59261539
25 0.0000000.0000120.0000000.0000126.0718e-0630
26 0.0178800.0176930.0038710.0316850.01777839
27 0.0588380.1288830.0020610.1880880.09507537
28 0.1072930.0905560.0000000.1965020.09825132
29 0.1452090.4193650.1908250.4159430.30338439
30 0.0157610.0049130.0059410.0139860.00996335
Avg 0.120622 0.130651 0.089407 0.161910 0.125658 35.633333