EMPIRE10 Banner

Results for brno

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used (article_brno.pdf)

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.000000 17.835000 3.360510 11.000000 44.000000 35.466667
Fissures 0.000000 9.238940 1.893951 16.500000 44.000000 31.516667
Landmarks 0.532791 29.185100 7.136487 21.000000 44.000000 35.766667
Singularities 0.013143 5.862240 1.433619 37.000000 44.000000 41.066667
Average 35.954167

Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)		 Ranking
01 0.079249 0.476113 0.025713 0.447481 0.277342 34
02 23.486000 8.450530 15.159300 16.087500 15.636000 43
03 18.418800 4.031640 9.834510 12.650400 11.243400 44
04 0.000082 0.000000 0.000068 0.000000 0.000034 11
05 7.579090 0.942740 3.129270 5.192880 4.187200 43
06 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 19.0
07 6.682660 1.794980 3.276720 5.123160 4.337620 42
08 0.221662 0.008086 0.065205 0.159132 0.117673 41
09 21.207500 13.883700 16.034500 18.159800 17.080800 44
10 0.002032 0.024475 0.030229 0.000034 0.015180 33
11 1.429100 0.282078 0.423786 1.179060 0.853071 42
12 1.971380 0.034387 0.681650 1.336270 1.035240 43
13 0.000437 0.002945 0.002992 0.000527 0.001673 28
14 0.184488 0.199391 0.157805 0.221180 0.192043 29
15 0.073253 0.564180 0.028252 0.540047 0.311983 39
16 0.443823 0.101088 0.484972 0.119191 0.276517 42
17 0.001080 0.035548 0.000060 0.036388 0.019152 40
18 1.059250 0.919582 0.013833 1.760590 0.989586 40
19 7.034980 0.384532 3.166040 4.414090 3.870180 43
20 0.031831 0.036614 0.016330 0.048838 0.034201 27
21 18.169600 4.306420 11.882400 10.993900 11.358200 42
22 9.227580 2.218450 4.648240 6.845710 5.817910 44
23 0.001841 0.000488 0.000000 0.002064 0.001168 31
24 0.002749 0.000396 0.000614 0.002165 0.001419 31
25 25.394400 11.291600 16.418600 19.275000 17.835000 44
26 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 11.0
27 5.555790 1.209670 2.610060 4.043000 3.370780 43
28 0.190214 0.443714 0.050163 0.523362 0.316117 34
29 0.000014 0.000000 0.000013 0.000000 6.2185e-06 14
30 2.894710 0.314238 1.364590 1.858670 1.635810 43
Avg 5.044786 1.731920 2.983531 3.700681 3.360510 35.466667

Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)		 Ranking
01 0.158871 1.480390 1.221690 29
02 6.611030 8.114810 7.555100 43
03 8.132880 0.778303 2.698490 42
04 0.000000 0.007849 0.004214 42
05 0.038327 0.002658 0.025601 39
06 0.000000 0.007085 0.004311 17.5
07 0.945686 4.043620 2.386030 32
08 0.007204 0.123788 0.076174 23
09 12.351200 7.614190 9.238940 44
10 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 18.5
11 1.313780 0.022743 0.449650 27
12 0.040591 0.006823 0.018319 33
13 0.173333 0.148854 0.164745 32
14 12.256700 2.197280 6.876460 30
15 0.223378 0.000000 0.101163 38
16 0.458592 2.928140 2.335150 40
17 0.134905 0.000000 0.052356 18.0
18 9.568290 0.644568 4.166180 30
19 0.477113 0.150611 0.295397 41
20 3.003500 7.704400 5.910190 35
21 4.032920 5.483310 5.019950 33
22 1.143480 0.636537 0.896091 39
23 0.042445 0.112486 0.084574 19.5
24 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 16.5
25 3.181590 5.361990 4.610120 43
26 0.011626 0.000000 0.003403 34.0
27 0.090883 0.406208 0.280472 36
28 1.665050 2.695290 2.326930 17
29 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 17.5
30 0.041637 0.001387 0.016838 36
Avg 2.203500 1.689111 1.893951 31.516667

Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)		 Ranking
01 4.601490 6.419000 2.745940 9.841690 8.873900 0.679688 23.505000 9.348120 36
02 11.285200 0.469000 14.519500 17.991800 20.193200 7.861180 28.352500 19.048500 43
03 7.453120 0.350000 9.885940 12.375700 13.578300 5.400400 19.712500 12.965000 44
04 1.497200 1.388010 0.657649 3.507560 1.281290 0.000000 17.149200 2.377810 32
05 4.580630 0.336000 5.473120 6.990800 7.937020 3.355090 12.207000 7.454450 41
06 0.310781 0.195000 0.213281 0.615935 0.597966 0.000000 2.284890 0.604435 32
07 3.550080 3.038000 5.205240 8.584680 8.099670 1.298620 32.837400 8.256330 37
08 1.515000 0.714000 2.100000 2.969410 3.081770 0.750000 8.728400 3.030090 34
09 18.416000 0.756000 21.369100 28.582700 29.812200 13.569000 44.207200 29.185100 44
10 2.448690 3.116310 1.378260 7.076110 2.120020 0.000000 21.648600 4.561080 35
11 2.358260 0.819000 2.723830 3.891460 4.271000 1.595370 19.248900 4.027140 39
12 2.225370 0.504000 3.279900 4.234840 4.290370 1.044620 8.697350 4.265380 39
13 0.390625 0.525000 0.410156 1.115900 0.895270 0.000000 10.575800 0.996759 21
14 4.682460 4.879000 1.997230 7.803460 8.425220 0.000000 37.567700 8.108120 32
15 0.618750 0.532000 0.358594 0.988667 1.133050 0.000000 5.879410 1.069520 32
16 0.742187 1.650000 0.859375 1.944050 2.902220 0.000000 36.624400 2.442300 36
17 0.458983 0.740000 0.556639 1.407530 1.418310 0.000000 6.309890 1.384340 30
18 3.691410 3.913000 1.469730 6.102950 6.666920 0.000000 29.263200 6.384940 34
19 4.589840 0.483000 5.170000 6.997050 7.307740 2.322300 14.047700 7.139970 40
20 2.534140 5.075000 1.878320 6.979460 6.082800 0.636719 29.308700 6.602860 32
21 7.526370 7.700000 9.428070 19.936700 13.198500 4.415940 47.884300 16.089100 36
22 4.945310 1.092000 6.679690 9.090490 8.944580 2.567780 18.272400 9.008780 44
23 0.322266 0.575000 0.312500 0.904127 1.158740 0.000000 2.856110 1.039070 27
24 1.642400 0.974967 1.209610 3.572110 0.891610 0.000000 23.707300 2.445080 37
25 13.443800 0.637000 17.737900 22.484800 24.044900 12.106200 32.934200 23.186800 44
26 0.304219 0.105000 0.200508 0.665224 0.419978 0.000000 1.651680 0.532791 24
27 4.225250 0.427000 5.540450 7.238380 7.266330 3.206840 10.765600 7.252910 40
28 3.631410 5.187000 2.440780 6.400680 8.760070 0.000000 32.399100 7.563560 35
29 1.067410 1.004620 0.931141 2.751520 0.821544 0.000000 12.614500 1.921180 33
30 3.355270 0.728000 4.196090 5.376020 6.213420 1.790600 24.909800 5.803090 40
Avg 3.947131 1.811064 4.364285 7.280727 7.022930 2.086678 20.538358 7.136487 35.766667

Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)		 Ranking
01 2.118600 3.723390 1.782320 4.306960 3.044640 41
02 0.017413 0.009095 0.002705 0.023581 0.013143 40
03 0.389572 0.180441 0.280111 0.281800 0.280956 42
04 4.117290 3.926440 5.607350 2.391030 3.999190 43
05 0.042368 0.081130 0.033035 0.091367 0.062201 42
06 0.025088 0.023298 0.025671 0.022730 0.024201 40
07 1.656970 3.766770 2.464680 2.866870 2.665770 41
08 0.373506 0.442078 0.405654 0.413255 0.409455 41
09 0.437569 0.315345 0.451016 0.297682 0.374349 42
10 5.252130 6.239460 7.962260 3.762220 5.862240 44
11 1.226110 0.251242 0.214433 1.134600 0.674517 41
12 0.130570 0.311392 0.246156 0.214440 0.230298 42
13 0.109001 0.109075 0.036479 0.181592 0.109035 37
14 2.822430 3.376520 3.565110 2.636320 3.100720 40
15 0.784412 1.292980 1.096480 1.007940 1.052210 41
16 0.750930 0.652175 1.000890 0.386159 0.693526 41
17 0.027875 0.041084 0.016938 0.053396 0.035167 39
18 1.980030 2.377100 1.883630 2.479480 2.181560 40
19 0.423913 0.191163 0.103021 0.476346 0.289683 42
20 2.356830 2.687750 1.912880 3.164590 2.538730 41
21 3.069640 6.014740 4.696170 4.565470 4.630820 40
22 1.047670 1.448640 0.705476 1.813870 1.259670 41
23 0.154228 0.095902 0.098271 0.148728 0.123499 40
24 2.209400 2.641200 3.366780 1.560050 2.463420 43
25 0.081038 0.563507 0.109366 0.558766 0.334066 42
26 0.027272 0.016777 0.016304 0.026789 0.021547 41
27 0.050267 0.297841 0.235756 0.120934 0.178345 40
28 1.939910 3.268760 2.130420 3.185200 2.657810 40
29 3.147530 2.847010 3.323820 2.624470 2.974140 43
30 1.390690 0.142621 0.247834 1.199490 0.723660 42
Avg 1.272008 1.577831 1.467367 1.399871 1.433619 41.066667