Results for amc_mirl

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used (article_amc_mirl.pdf)

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.0003463.6558900.96731132.00000043.00000038.233333
Fissures 0.0000006.6273401.3216816.00000042.00000028.300000
Landmarks 0.64003110.0467003.4002848.00000040.00000032.166667
Singularities 0.8388717.8673703.63329737.00000043.00000041.733333
Average 35.108333

Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 2.5442901.6093700.6108343.1311302.10017040
02 0.0011090.0022260.0034800.0000980.00164837
03 0.0132810.0160980.0190580.0104290.01461836
04 0.0129220.0066650.0184920.0000140.00929137
05 0.0089680.0020740.0100750.0013210.00561037
06 0.0005990.0000830.0002240.0004470.00034640
07 1.7044804.6298702.3447003.6268403.06131038
08 7.1749200.0262732.8565604.2970903.64926042
09 0.0123910.0019020.0020170.0118930.00729535
10 0.1515390.1101930.2507280.0039920.12757740
11 0.5751050.2637980.0191980.7272870.41879238
12 0.0259750.0035330.0019820.0263960.01513736
13 0.0217823.0293100.3486482.5150501.50885043
14 0.8983413.0558703.2129800.8940751.99039039
15 0.1159860.0131090.0024900.1183370.06581837
16 0.2723380.0398780.0359250.2520960.15924740
17 0.3732300.0160610.0912090.2705500.18492742
18 2.5013901.7413201.6829002.4879302.13005040
19 0.0003650.0088460.0031360.0051830.00431338
20 1.7360301.2182301.9988501.0331101.48227040
21 4.3025202.9841902.1122204.7841403.65589037
22 5.0944400.0711091.9659203.2634402.62190041
23 4.6806000.0237892.0138902.6082102.34897042
24 0.0028670.0006340.0014840.0017660.00163132
25 0.4859330.0012770.0063010.4562910.24710040
26 0.0006350.0014680.0011250.0010180.00106334
27 0.0061660.0076950.0037440.0095500.00692233
28 2.3356501.2639800.5117622.8513901.80344038
29 0.0046470.0051890.0100370.0002430.00494635
30 2.7096400.0019860.7564581.9213901.39056040
Avg 1.258938 0.671867 0.696548 1.177024 0.967311 38.233333

Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.0645593.7617703.03802032
02 0.0000000.0000000.00000017.0
03 0.0016890.0001990.00058830.5
04 0.0000000.0000000.00000019.5
05 0.0000000.0005910.00021136
06 0.0267350.0121460.01785937
07 0.2448452.9664501.51022028
08 13.6781000.0114675.59308039
09 0.0000000.0000000.00000010.0
10 0.0000000.0000000.00000018.5
11 0.1363720.0154480.05543420
12 0.0000000.0031710.00209230
13 0.2442752.6509501.08864038
14 1.8527900.5827441.1735106
15 0.0071450.0013920.00399728
16 3.8980300.9291621.64205035
17 2.5489900.0450331.01681042
18 6.0654600.3049832.57827023
19 0.0020380.0005000.00118236
20 0.4451044.4101802.89682027
21 4.2354207.7502206.62734037
22 2.1186800.0100031.08964041
23 12.7759000.1687295.19283038
24 0.0000000.0000000.00000016.0
25 5.1921600.0002201.92553041
26 0.0072660.0000000.00212718.0
27 0.0086560.0017370.00449625
28 1.5328005.5068104.08592026
29 0.0000000.0000000.00000017.0
30 0.2674140.0018030.10376337.5
Avg 1.845148 0.971190 1.321681 28.300000

Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 3.8878103.3110003.6839106.9829107.3253000.97569219.8172007.15753033
02 0.1968750.3290000.3093750.5821110.7876460.0000002.1093800.68076829
03 0.4148440.3850000.4359370.9022840.9359620.0000003.9774800.91878633
04 0.4617540.4835660.6646451.3697900.9114740.0000007.1505701.13721020
05 0.5250000.6300000.5643751.0275201.4330900.0000005.3089101.22625037
06 0.3168750.2550000.2254690.6086730.6576700.0000003.9603100.64003132
07 2.4595302.1000003.1169505.0472005.3830100.00000017.7462005.16464032
08 2.2050002.9190003.9075005.7034106.2466500.70000020.2354005.99676039
09 0.5126950.4550000.5605471.1010201.1331800.0000003.6935801.11678034
10 0.5597020.6447541.3222902.2671101.3409800.4687509.4440501.79713021
11 1.2543901.3090000.9891801.9193303.1047300.70000013.5088002.44542035
12 0.7521290.7140000.7521291.5768401.5483300.0000004.9537101.56116036
13 2.1777301.5625001.9043002.9711304.4075900.00000012.3428003.74682039
14 4.7693002.5550003.4934809.5474905.3235001.17574035.3178007.47774030
15 0.9492191.6450001.5609402.8440602.6971700.0000006.5839202.76180038
16 1.4160201.1500002.6562503.9504303.5049900.00000011.6597003.71880036
17 1.7578101.4800001.2988302.8448603.7054400.0000008.9916403.18383040
18 2.8779303.2480002.1054706.3897204.6160800.68359415.6012005.50289031
19 0.6168750.8190000.8371881.5628301.5498800.0000003.6848601.55687036
20 4.0431602.4360002.3558607.4975904.0950500.63671916.6876006.06853030
21 5.6173505.6000004.1471809.44082010.7392001.59537019.55530010.04670031
22 2.4453101.9390003.6718805.0816605.5983000.00000016.3056005.37098037
23 1.5820302.6500003.0175805.6557204.3188800.00000012.9871004.94720038
24 0.4050510.5386180.3107241.0898400.6624330.0000003.1924100.91013318
25 1.8697700.9590000.7749222.3486702.7025300.0000008.9512402.50791038
26 0.3318750.2700000.2765620.5682380.8597390.0000002.6514900.72564830
27 0.5820120.5110000.5064261.1830401.1478800.0000005.2299601.16476033
28 4.1002203.4090003.2891007.3744807.1489101.02164022.9502007.18344033
29 0.3122730.3348720.4201490.7702730.8063760.0000001.8599500.7858068
30 1.9378902.2820002.6265604.3923904.6155200.00000017.3031004.50619038
Avg 1.711281 1.564144 1.726190 3.486715 3.310250 0.265250 11.125382 3.400284 32.166667

Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 4.0495106.7627303.8827607.3475805.61517041
02 1.5611301.5372901.2922301.8055601.54889042
03 4.8146004.7760005.3899804.1991204.79455043
04 1.1797301.0803600.7592261.4772501.11824039
05 0.0365682.2328401.1192801.2013301.16030043
06 3.6240804.4775603.2512104.8432304.04722043
07 5.5751706.9628904.1990408.2783806.23871042
08 0.00505711.5201005.4935506.5898606.04170043
09 3.3490803.0456103.4481302.9361003.19211043
10 1.2270901.1548300.9331851.4316901.18244040
11 4.2204003.8877802.6633105.4010804.03220042
12 2.9339302.3029302.9504602.2213702.58592043
13 6.9717600.0046243.6907103.7772103.73396043
14 6.5521907.3740805.4662508.4637106.96498040
15 0.0481174.2490201.9148602.6055702.26022042
16 0.0000008.9126503.7003606.6610605.18071041
17 0.0001604.6442302.5077602.6197202.56374043
18 6.7348608.9662906.0619909.6727507.86737042
19 0.0000008.1850904.5799404.8609604.72045043
20 6.2642406.7751605.0751908.0149806.54509041
21 2.9381204.6303901.4056506.2647303.83519037
22 0.0121833.8524001.8476002.2375902.04260042
23 0.0000007.2734004.2816603.3822303.83195041
24 0.9742050.9981880.8394031.1372200.98831340
25 0.0346391.5681301.0366200.6411240.83887142
26 3.2073603.2221402.6091503.8216903.21542043
27 3.0626003.5764303.1022903.5545603.32842043
28 6.0868907.9219005.0291109.1273607.07824042
29 1.0523701.0551600.9832411.1247201.05398040
30 0.0005202.6040001.2118301.5720601.39195043
Avg 2.550552 4.518473 3.024199 4.242393 3.633297 41.733333