Results for amc_mirl

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used (article_amc_mirl.pdf)

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

	Scores			Rankings
	Min	Max	Average	Min	Max	Average
Lung Boundaries	0.000346	3.655890	0.967311	32.000000	44.000000	39.066667
Fissures	0.000000	6.627340	1.321681	7.000000	43.000000	29.183333
Landmarks	0.640031	10.046700	3.400284	8.000000	41.000000	33.066667
Singularities	0.838871	7.867370	3.633297	38.000000	44.000000	42.733333
Average						36.012500

Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair	% Error Left Lung	% Error Right Lung	% Error Upper Lung	% Error Lower Lung	Score (% Error Overall)	Ranking
01	2.544290	1.609370	0.610834	3.131130	2.100170	41
02	0.001109	0.002226	0.003480	0.000098	0.001648	37
03	0.013281	0.016098	0.019058	0.010429	0.014618	37
04	0.012922	0.006665	0.018492	0.000014	0.009291	37
05	0.008968	0.002074	0.010075	0.001321	0.005610	38
06	0.000599	0.000083	0.000224	0.000447	0.000346	41
07	1.704480	4.629870	2.344700	3.626840	3.061310	39
08	7.174920	0.026273	2.856560	4.297090	3.649260	43
09	0.012391	0.001902	0.002017	0.011893	0.007295	36
10	0.151539	0.110193	0.250728	0.003992	0.127577	40
11	0.575105	0.263798	0.019198	0.727287	0.418792	39
12	0.025975	0.003533	0.001982	0.026396	0.015137	37
13	0.021782	3.029310	0.348648	2.515050	1.508850	44
14	0.898341	3.055870	3.212980	0.894075	1.990390	40
15	0.115986	0.013109	0.002490	0.118337	0.065818	38
16	0.272338	0.039878	0.035925	0.252096	0.159247	41
17	0.373230	0.016061	0.091209	0.270550	0.184927	43
18	2.501390	1.741320	1.682900	2.487930	2.130050	41
19	0.000365	0.008846	0.003136	0.005183	0.004313	39
20	1.736030	1.218230	1.998850	1.033110	1.482270	41
21	4.302520	2.984190	2.112220	4.784140	3.655890	38
22	5.094440	0.071109	1.965920	3.263440	2.621900	42
23	4.680600	0.023789	2.013890	2.608210	2.348970	43
24	0.002867	0.000634	0.001484	0.001766	0.001631	32
25	0.485933	0.001277	0.006301	0.456291	0.247100	41
26	0.000635	0.001468	0.001125	0.001018	0.001063	35
27	0.006166	0.007695	0.003744	0.009550	0.006922	34
28	2.335650	1.263980	0.511762	2.851390	1.803440	39
29	0.004647	0.005189	0.010037	0.000243	0.004946	35
30	2.709640	0.001986	0.756458	1.921390	1.390560	41
Avg	1.258938	0.671867	0.696548	1.177024	0.967311	39.066667

Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair	% Error Left Lung	% Error Right Lung	Score (% Error Overall)	Ranking
01	0.064559	3.761770	3.038020	33
02	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	17.5
03	0.001689	0.000199	0.000588	31.5
04	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	20.0
05	0.000000	0.000591	0.000211	37
06	0.026735	0.012146	0.017859	38
07	0.244845	2.966450	1.510220	29
08	13.678100	0.011467	5.593080	40
09	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	10.5
10	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	18.5
11	0.136372	0.015448	0.055434	21
12	0.000000	0.003171	0.002092	31
13	0.244275	2.650950	1.088640	39
14	1.852790	0.582744	1.173510	7
15	0.007145	0.001392	0.003997	29
16	3.898030	0.929162	1.642050	36
17	2.548990	0.045033	1.016810	43
18	6.065460	0.304983	2.578270	24
19	0.002038	0.000500	0.001182	37
20	0.445104	4.410180	2.896820	28
21	4.235420	7.750220	6.627340	38
22	2.118680	0.010003	1.089640	42
23	12.775900	0.168729	5.192830	39
24	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	16.5
25	5.192160	0.000220	1.925530	42
26	0.007266	0.000000	0.002127	19.0
27	0.008656	0.001737	0.004496	26
28	1.532800	5.506810	4.085920	27
29	0.000000	0.000000	0.000000	17.5
30	0.267414	0.001803	0.103763	38.5
Avg	1.845148	0.971190	1.321681	29.183333

Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair	Avg Dist AP	Avg Dist SI	Avg Dist LR	Avg Dist Upper Lung	Avg Dist Lower Lung	Min Dist	Max Dist	Score (Avg Dist)	Ranking
01	3.887810	3.311000	3.683910	6.982910	7.325300	0.975692	19.817200	7.157530	34
02	0.196875	0.329000	0.309375	0.582111	0.787646	0.000000	2.109380	0.680768	30
03	0.414844	0.385000	0.435937	0.902284	0.935962	0.000000	3.977480	0.918786	34
04	0.461754	0.483566	0.664645	1.369790	0.911474	0.000000	7.150570	1.137210	21
05	0.525000	0.630000	0.564375	1.027520	1.433090	0.000000	5.308910	1.226250	38
06	0.316875	0.255000	0.225469	0.608673	0.657670	0.000000	3.960310	0.640031	33
07	2.459530	2.100000	3.116950	5.047200	5.383010	0.000000	17.746200	5.164640	33
08	2.205000	2.919000	3.907500	5.703410	6.246650	0.700000	20.235400	5.996760	40
09	0.512695	0.455000	0.560547	1.101020	1.133180	0.000000	3.693580	1.116780	35
10	0.559702	0.644754	1.322290	2.267110	1.340980	0.468750	9.444050	1.797130	21
11	1.254390	1.309000	0.989180	1.919330	3.104730	0.700000	13.508800	2.445420	36
12	0.752129	0.714000	0.752129	1.576840	1.548330	0.000000	4.953710	1.561160	37
13	2.177730	1.562500	1.904300	2.971130	4.407590	0.000000	12.342800	3.746820	40
14	4.769300	2.555000	3.493480	9.547490	5.323500	1.175740	35.317800	7.477740	31
15	0.949219	1.645000	1.560940	2.844060	2.697170	0.000000	6.583920	2.761800	39
16	1.416020	1.150000	2.656250	3.950430	3.504990	0.000000	11.659700	3.718800	37
17	1.757810	1.480000	1.298830	2.844860	3.705440	0.000000	8.991640	3.183830	41
18	2.877930	3.248000	2.105470	6.389720	4.616080	0.683594	15.601200	5.502890	32
19	0.616875	0.819000	0.837188	1.562830	1.549880	0.000000	3.684860	1.556870	37
20	4.043160	2.436000	2.355860	7.497590	4.095050	0.636719	16.687600	6.068530	31
21	5.617350	5.600000	4.147180	9.440820	10.739200	1.595370	19.555300	10.046700	32
22	2.445310	1.939000	3.671880	5.081660	5.598300	0.000000	16.305600	5.370980	38
23	1.582030	2.650000	3.017580	5.655720	4.318880	0.000000	12.987100	4.947200	39
24	0.405051	0.538618	0.310724	1.089840	0.662433	0.000000	3.192410	0.910133	18
25	1.869770	0.959000	0.774922	2.348670	2.702530	0.000000	8.951240	2.507910	39
26	0.331875	0.270000	0.276562	0.568238	0.859739	0.000000	2.651490	0.725648	31
27	0.582012	0.511000	0.506426	1.183040	1.147880	0.000000	5.229960	1.164760	34
28	4.100220	3.409000	3.289100	7.374480	7.148910	1.021640	22.950200	7.183440	34
29	0.312273	0.334872	0.420149	0.770273	0.806376	0.000000	1.859950	0.785806	8
30	1.937890	2.282000	2.626560	4.392390	4.615520	0.000000	17.303100	4.506190	39
Avg	1.711281	1.564144	1.726190	3.486715	3.310250	0.265250	11.125382	3.400284	33.066667

Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair	% Error Left Lung	% Error Right Lung	% Error Upper Lung	% Error Lower Lung	Score (% Error Overall)	Ranking
01	4.049510	6.762730	3.882760	7.347580	5.615170	42
02	1.561130	1.537290	1.292230	1.805560	1.548890	43
03	4.814600	4.776000	5.389980	4.199120	4.794550	44
04	1.179730	1.080360	0.759226	1.477250	1.118240	40
05	0.036568	2.232840	1.119280	1.201330	1.160300	44
06	3.624080	4.477560	3.251210	4.843230	4.047220	44
07	5.575170	6.962890	4.199040	8.278380	6.238710	43
08	0.005057	11.520100	5.493550	6.589860	6.041700	44
09	3.349080	3.045610	3.448130	2.936100	3.192110	44
10	1.227090	1.154830	0.933185	1.431690	1.182440	41
11	4.220400	3.887780	2.663310	5.401080	4.032200	43
12	2.933930	2.302930	2.950460	2.221370	2.585920	44
13	6.971760	0.004624	3.690710	3.777210	3.733960	44
14	6.552190	7.374080	5.466250	8.463710	6.964980	41
15	0.048117	4.249020	1.914860	2.605570	2.260220	43
16	0.000000	8.912650	3.700360	6.661060	5.180710	42
17	0.000160	4.644230	2.507760	2.619720	2.563740	44
18	6.734860	8.966290	6.061990	9.672750	7.867370	43
19	0.000000	8.185090	4.579940	4.860960	4.720450	44
20	6.264240	6.775160	5.075190	8.014980	6.545090	42
21	2.938120	4.630390	1.405650	6.264730	3.835190	38
22	0.012183	3.852400	1.847600	2.237590	2.042600	43
23	0.000000	7.273400	4.281660	3.382230	3.831950	42
24	0.974205	0.998188	0.839403	1.137220	0.988313	41
25	0.034639	1.568130	1.036620	0.641124	0.838871	43
26	3.207360	3.222140	2.609150	3.821690	3.215420	44
27	3.062600	3.576430	3.102290	3.554560	3.328420	44
28	6.086890	7.921900	5.029110	9.127360	7.078240	43
29	1.052370	1.055160	0.983241	1.124720	1.053980	41
30	0.000520	2.604000	1.211830	1.572060	1.391950	44
Avg	2.550552	4.518473	3.024199	4.242393	3.633297	42.733333